Tuesday 27 January 2009

Meteor Garden VS Hana Yori Dango VS Kgotboda Namja

So guys.. which versions of Hana Yori Dango that you think look the best???

1st, The mother of all Asian Dramas, Meteor Garden~ 
this is when all the Asian Dramas trend started~


2nd, The original Hana Yori Dango dorama, why i said original since it's under the Japanese production itself  :)
and they speak in Japanese! so it feels Original!

3rd, the Korean version, i read that the Korean production made the whole sets of the filming even more similar to the manga version, even the houses, their outfits.....which is kinda true.. 

and it's the 3rd time of watching the same manga adaption dramas, just out of curiousity~~ 
oh well, i think it's the 4th time already, since in Indonesia, there was once an adaption of Meteor Garden being aired on TV, but they never aired the whole episodes, it was only aired until 4-5 episodes, if i'm not wrong. It was stopped because so many MG fans protested because the Indonesian version didn't ask for the copyright permission of adapting, and the production house denied that they ever copied the storyline... oh well, who did they think they like to fool? even a 5 years old kid understood what was Meteor Garden at the time~ but, they knew they couldn't win the debate with all the loyal MG fans, that's why they stopped airing it~
Oh yea, the title of the Indonesian version was kinda lame, it was called "Siapa Takut Jatuh Cinta?" (Who's afraid of falling in love?)
actually, i'm trying to googling the pics of the casts, but i can't find out haha :D
..back to which version is the best..through out all the official Hana Yori Dango adaption dramas.
i think i'll vote for the Korean version..
since... arhhgahhh~ all the Korean boys look Handsomeee!!!!!
just exactly like i've been expecting~
actually, i've never fallen into Doumyouji Tsukasa/Dao Ming Tse character before..but...gahh the Korean version Go Jun Pyo (acted by Lee Min Ho) has attracted me right from the start, even before i watched the 1st episode.. even just looking at the pic..Woahhh he is definitely suitable for the role :)
and know what, i'll usually fall over Hanazawa Rui/Hua Ze Lei character because i think the character seems nicer?~~ which i did when i watched MG and Hana Yori Dango..but this Korean version really gives me a different view :)
Before the Korean version was out, i used to say that Meteor Garden F4 members were much better than the Japanese F4 members.. i know it's the original F4, since they're Japanese itself.. but just...kinda think that the actors were not really suitable.. because they were not really similar to the Manga version, they were not tall at all.. (no offense to the Japanese version fans~), but as for now, i think the Korean version F4 members are the best :) even though the Tsukasa is the tallest among the 4..but at least, the other 3 have the same height :) and their actings are pretty convinced :)

so my rank is:
1. Korean version
2. Taiwanese version
3. Japanese version

so what are we going to see next? Chinese version?
i ever read a rumor that thre will be China version of HND too..
if so, i can't wait!

1 comment:

  1. ohh~~ really, but my rank is:
    1. Taiwanese version
    2. Japanese version
    3. Korean version
    -nymph-

    ReplyDelete